How do you know when your solution has become the problem?

The clearest signal is that pushing harder on the solution produces no results or makes things worse. Paul Veth recommends going back to the original goal and asking whether your current activity is bringing that goal closer. If not, the solution is the obstacle.

Is competing with other businesses always a mistake?

Paul says competition can be a legitimate strategy, but only in the right context. When you are fighting over a fixed pool of customers, everyone loses. Growing the total market with others, including competitors, almost always works better. The bar street example in Breda tripled foot traffic once collaboration replaced competition.

How often should an entrepreneur re-evaluate whether their focus is right?

Paul suggests doing this every quarter or at minimum every year. The question is simple: is what I am doing right now bringing my original goal closer? Services, tactics and strategies that cannot answer yes to that question may not belong in the business at all.

What does Paul mean when he says marketing is noise?

Paul uses marketing as an example of a legitimate activity that still becomes noise when it pulls focus away from the core goal. The goal is to solve a problem for a customer. Everything built around that goal, including marketing, only matters if it brings more of the right people closer to that solution.

When Your Solution Becomes the Problem

Core Idea

When your solution stops working, the instinct is to optimize it harder. Paul Veth argues that is often the wrong move. The solution itself may have become the obstacle. The fix is to trace back to the original goal and ask one question: is what I am doing right now bringing that goal closer?

The Bar Story

Paul's first business was a bar on a C-location street in Breda, the third street people reached after the A and B locations filled up. He competed aggressively against neighboring bars for months. The result: everyone on the street lost ground. Winning one weekend meant losing the next. When he stopped competing and approached the other bar owners about working together, foot traffic on the whole street grew significantly. The competitive fight had been the wrong focus all along.

The Pattern Paul Describes

You identify a problem and build a solution.
The solution becomes your main focus point.
If the solution stops working, you push harder on it.
The solution has now become the problem.
You need to go back to the original goal, not forward into the broken solution.

The Question to Ask Regularly

Paul recommends returning to this question every quarter or every year: is this thing I am doing bringing my goal closer? If the answer is unclear or no, that activity may need to be cut, not scaled. His bar example comes back to one sentence: he was there to give people a great time. Everything else, including fighting competitors, was noise around that goal.

Key Framework

Paul references the difference between zero-sum thinking (one winner, one loser) and positive-sum thinking (growing the whole market together). The positive-sum approach almost always works better, as the Breda street example shows. Identity First Marketing, the strategy practice of Paul Veth, applies this same logic: start with the goal, not the tactic.

Your Solution Might Be the Problem

Key takeaways

Timestamps

Show notes

Core Idea

The Bar Story

The Pattern Paul Describes

The Question to Ask Regularly

Key Framework

Topics

Full transcript

Frequently asked questions

Related episodes

Your State Is Your Marketing

Launch a Brand in One Day

He Asked for the World. I Asked for Groceries.

Get in touch

Discussion